Sunday, November 22, 2026
Google search engine
HomeStoriesCourt Clears Boda Boda Lenders as Crash Victim Is Left Chasing Rider

Court Clears Boda Boda Lenders as Crash Victim Is Left Chasing Rider

Court Clears Boda Boda Lenders as Crash Victim Is Left Chasing Rider

Two High Court judges rule that holding a motorcycle’s logbook as loan security does not make Watu Credit Limited or Watu Nominees Company Limited liable for riders’ accidents.

A woman from Trans Nzoia whose leg was shattered in a boda boda accident six years ago must now pursue the rider for her Sh705,550 compensation after the High Court ruled that the company which financed his motorcycle cannot be held responsible.

In Kitale, Justice Joseph Were set aside a magistrate’s finding that Watu Credit Limited was jointly liable with the borrower, Felix N. Chesoli, for injuries suffered by Sarah Nanjala Kunguru.

Ms Nanjala was a pillion passenger on a motorcycle that was hit from behind at Maili Tatu, along the Kitale–Webuye road, on July 23, 2020.

On the same day, November 12, Justice E. Ogola in Nairobi dismissed a motorist’s attempt to make Watu Nominees Company Limited pay an Sh800,000 award. He ruled that simply being the registered owner of a motorcycle used as loan security does not create liability for an accident without evidence that the rider was acting as the company’s agent or under its control.

The two rulings add to a series of High Court decisions protecting lenders who retain motorcycle ownership documents until borrowers complete their loan repayments.

The Kitale Case

Ms Nanjala suffered compound fractures of her right tibia and fibula and was left with a 19cm scar. An eyewitness told the trial court that the motorcycle behind had rammed the one she was travelling on before its rider fled. Mr Chesoli did not respond to the suit.

In October 2024, Resident Magistrate Irene Kabuteh found Watu Credit and Mr Chesoli jointly liable. She noted that the company was the motorcycle’s registered owner and that the borrower had stopped repaying his loan in April 2020, three months before the accident.

Watu Credit’s branch administrator told the court that Mr Chesoli had bought the motorcycle on credit for Sh162,377, payable in weekly instalments of Sh2,662. He was also the person riding it.

The loan agreement allowed the lender to install a tracking device, switch off the motorcycle remotely, arrange insurance at the borrower’s expense and repossess it in the event of default.

However, Justice Were said these provisions were simply intended to protect the lender’s collateral and secure loan repayment. They did not establish control over who rode the motorcycle, where it was taken or the purpose of its use.

“The fact that the loan remained unpaid and the Appellant remained the registered owner did not on its own establish vicarious liability,” the judge ruled.

He found that Ms Nanjala had not proved that Mr Chesoli was an employee or agent of Watu Credit. The rider alone must therefore pay the award, while Ms Nanjala must also meet Watu Credit’s costs of the trial.

The judge clarified that his decision did not affect any rights Ms Nanjala might have against the motorcycle’s insurer. However, the judgment did not identify the insurer.

A Similar Ruling in Nairobi

In the second case, motorist Salome Wangari Kihara was found entirely to blame for a December 2024 collision on North Airport Road, near Cabanas.

A pillion passenger, Mary Ouma Achieng, suffered a fractured left femur in the crash. Ms Kihara wanted Watu Nominees Company Limited, the motorcycle’s registered owner, to indemnify her for the Sh800,000 award.

She argued that the company had failed to register its security interest under the Movable Property Security Rights Act and was not a licensed credit provider.

Justice Ogola dismissed the arguments, saying the Act did not determine liability for injuries suffered by third parties in road accidents. He also held that a company’s regulatory status as a lender did not automatically make it responsible for a rider’s actions.

Both judges relied on a 2025 decision by Justice Mrima, who had similarly cleared Watu Nominees of liability.

Justice Ogola’s ruling is final under the Small Claims Court Act.

What the Rulings Mean

The decisions reinforce an important distinction between financing a motorcycle and controlling how it is used.

A lender may retain the logbook, track the motorcycle, remotely disable it or repossess it when a borrower defaults. However, those arrangements alone do not make the lender responsible for accidents caused by the rider.

For accident victims, the rulings also highlight the importance of establishing who was responsible for the accident and whether there is evidence linking another party to the rider’s actions.

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -
Google search engine

Most Popular

Recent Comments